Let be an abelian group. Prove that is a subgroup of (called the torsion subgroup of ). Give an explicit example where this set is not a subgroup when is non-abelian.
A solution: Let . Since the identity is of order 1, it lies in and therefore is not empty. Now if , we have for some positive integers and . Then , so that . Therefore, by the Subgroup Criterion, is a subgroup.
An explicit example when is not a group is the infinite dihedral group, . In , both and have order 2, but has infinite order. Thus, is not closed under the group operation.